Why Co-Parenting Counseling Can Be Difficult: Common Challenges After Separation and Divorce

By the time parents enter co-parenting counseling, the argument presented in the first session is rarely the first version of that argument.

A disagreement about a school decision may sit on top of years of conflict about who carried more responsibility for the children. A dispute about reimbursement may revive financial arguments from the marriage. A request to change a weekend can be heard through a history in which one parent felt controlled and the other felt chronically disregarded.

Parents are trying to establish a functional working relationship at a time when trust between them may be particularly low. Court-ordered co-parenting counseling adds another complication because one or both parents may be participating reluctantly, convinced that counseling is unnecessary or that the other parent is responsible for the problems between them.

Much of the work involves separating the history of the former relationship from the parenting decisions that still have to be made.

Parents May Have Very Different Accounts of the Marriage

Divorcing couples rarely leave a marriage with identical explanations of what happened.

One parent may describe the other as controlling; the other may describe years of assuming more responsibility because the former spouse was unreliable. One remembers repeated attempts to discuss problems, while the other remembers repeated criticism. Both can usually produce examples.

Those histories influence how new interactions are interpreted. A text that says, “Can you confirm pickup by 5?” may seem like an ordinary request to one parent and another instance of monitoring to the other. A delayed response may be insignificant to the person who sent it late and evidence of longstanding disregard to the person waiting for it.

Sessions can easily become consumed by attempts to establish whose account of the former relationship is correct. Facts require careful attention when safety, abuse, coercive control, substance misuse, or a child’s welfare is involved, and meaningful differences in behavior should be addressed directly rather than distributed equally between the parents.

Routine parenting decisions present a different problem because they continue regardless of whether former spouses ever agree about their history. Two parents may remain divided over whether a longstanding pattern began as control or as a response to unreliability while still needing a reliable procedure for confirming pickup.

Successful Co-Parenting Allows for Disagreement

Parents can have legitimate differences about how much independence a teenager should have, whether an extracurricular activity warrants the commitment, how closely homework should be supervised, appropriate bedtimes, screen use, food, clothing, or household responsibilities.

After separation, some decisions continue to require consultation, while others belong primarily to the parent responsible for the child at that time. A parent may strongly disagree with the amount of screen time permitted in the other household, for example, while having limited authority over that rule unless it affects the child’s health or safety, violates a court order, or concerns a matter requiring joint decision-making.

The distinction between “I believe this is a poor parenting decision” and “I am entitled to participate in this decision” can be emotionally difficult to accept, particularly when a parent feels strongly about the issue.

Clarifying which decisions require joint involvement and which remain within each household can reduce unnecessary negotiation. Children can adapt to different expectations in two homes, and parents can reserve their limited capacity for collaboration for decisions they genuinely need to make together.

Communication Can Become Part of the Conflict

Some high-conflict co-parents communicate extensively. The volume of communication can become part of the problem.

Messages grow longer because each parent wants a complete record. Every accusation receives an answer because leaving it unanswered feels dangerous. Minor inaccuracies are corrected because allowing them to stand feels like conceding something important. An exchange that begins with whether a child needs to bring a soccer uniform can end with several pages about who failed to communicate about activities during the previous school year.

From the perspective of each parent, the additional detail may feel necessary. Meanwhile, the question about the soccer uniform remains unanswered.

In strained co-parenting relationships, a single message can be expected to exchange information about the children, document grievances, defend against anticipated allegations, correct the historical record, and establish which parent is behaving reasonably. Each additional purpose creates another opportunity for disagreement.

Research on post-divorce co-parenting distinguishes conflictual co-parenting from more cooperative or supportive forms. Lamela and colleagues found associations among post-divorce co-parenting patterns, parental well-being, parenting quality, and children’s psychological adjustment.

A useful communication strategy is to give each exchange a narrow purpose. An email about the orthodontist can address the appointment, the treatment recommendation, the cost, and any decision the parents need to make. The history of which parent assumed greater responsibility for medical care belongs in a different conversation, if it needs to be discussed at all.

Litigation Changes What Happens in Counseling

Court involvement can affect what parents are willing to say and how they interpret what happens during counseling.

A parent may bring twenty pages of messages and want the therapist to understand what they establish. Another may be reluctant to acknowledge a mistake because of concern that the admission could later be used against them. Parents may listen for evidence that the therapist agrees with one person’s account, and a recommendation about communication can be interpreted as confirmation that the other parent has been behaving improperly.

The therapist’s role therefore needs to be defined carefully. Co-parenting counseling addresses the parents’ ability to manage their ongoing parenting responsibilities. Custody evaluations, determinations of credibility, parenting-time recommendations, and decisions about the legal merits of a dispute belong to different processes.

Sessions organized around persuading the therapist who is right leave progressively less time for the decisions and interactions the parents still have to manage.

Parents May Want Different Levels of Contact

One parent may want flexibility, frequent communication, and collaborative decision-making, while the other prefers limited contact and strict adherence to the parenting plan. Either arrangement can function well or poorly depending on the parents involved.

Frequent collaboration creates more opportunities for flexibility and joint problem-solving, along with more opportunities for conflict. A highly structured arrangement reduces the number of negotiations required and may be easier for parents whose attempts at flexibility repeatedly become adversarial.

This matters because a parent who wants less interaction can easily be characterized as resistant when frequent collaboration has been established as the preferred model. A parent seeking more flexibility may likewise be treated as unnecessarily intrusive when the parents are capable of coordinating effectively.

The appropriate level of contact depends on the decisions the parents need to make, the requirements of their parenting plan, the needs of their children, and their demonstrated ability to communicate without repeatedly escalating conflict.

Children Can Become Intermediaries

Strained communication between parents can gradually shift adult responsibilities onto children.

Some examples are obvious: “Tell your father you need to be home by six.”

Others sound like ordinary questions: “Did your mom say why she couldn’t take you to practice?” “Who was at Dad’s house this weekend?” “Did your mother tell you about the school meeting?”

A parent may genuinely want information, while the child may understand that the answer carries significance and begin paying attention to one household with the expectation that the information will be useful in the other.

Over time, children can end up carrying schedules, explanations, observations, complaints, and emotional information between homes. They may also learn to anticipate how information about one parent will affect the other and adjust what they say accordingly.

Research on interparental conflict has examined triangulation, loyalty conflicts, threat, self-blame, and changes in parenting associated with conflict between former partners. A meta-analysis by van Dijk and colleagues included 115 samples representing 24,854 divorced families and found significant associations among interparental conflict, parenting processes, and children’s adjustment.

Children will naturally talk about their lives in both homes. The concern arises when adults begin depending on them to obtain information, deliver messages, monitor the other household, or manage communication the parents find difficult to have directly.

Moving those responsibilities back to the adults can relieve children of a role they were never meant to occupy.

New Partners Require Thoughtful Boundaries

New relationships can raise questions about authority, privacy, loyalty, and the meaning of family after divorce.

A new partner may attend school events, help with homework, drive a child to practice, enforce rules within the household, or develop an important relationship with the child. The parent in that household may regard these activities as an ordinary part of family life, while the other parent experiences them as intrusive or fears being displaced.

Direct involvement in co-parenting disputes creates additional complications. New partners who send messages, confront the other parent, negotiate parenting decisions, or advocate aggressively for their partner can turn a disagreement between two parents into a conflict involving four adults.

Clear boundaries allow new partners to develop meaningful relationships with children while preserving parental decisions and disputes for the people who share responsibility for making them.

Financial Conflict Often Continues After Divorce

Parents continue making financial decisions for their children long after the marital finances have been separated.

Medical expenses, tutoring, extracurricular activities, private school, clothing, phones, cars, travel, and other costs can generate disagreement. Parenting plans and court orders resolve some of these questions, although no agreement can anticipate every expense that will arise as children grow.

A $150 reimbursement may also carry years of disagreement about control, entitlement, generosity, responsibility, or which parent historically carried more of the financial burden. Families with substantial resources can face additional complexity through private education, extensive activities, travel, trusts, family businesses, or large differences in income.

Procedures help contain these disputes. Parents can establish which expenses require advance consultation, what documentation should accompany reimbursement requests, how discretionary costs will be handled, and how quickly payment is expected. The governing parenting plan or court order provides the starting point where it addresses the expense.

Clear procedures reduce the number of financial decisions that require negotiation and make it harder for a routine reimbursement request to become another argument about the marriage.

The Same Behavior Can Have Different Explanations

Parents often begin counseling with concrete complaints:

“He doesn’t respond.”

“She changes the schedule.”

“He undermines my rules.”

“She sends too many messages.”

Understanding what maintains the behavior affects how it should be addressed.

A parent who does not respond may be avoiding conflict, attempting to exert control, overwhelmed by the volume of communication, or simply careless. Someone who sends repeated messages may be anxious about obtaining an answer, creating a record, accustomed to carrying the family’s administrative responsibilities, or trying to force engagement from someone who routinely fails to respond.

A requirement that parents respond within 24 hours may solve a problem created by unclear expectations. The same rule may accomplish very little when delayed responses are being used deliberately to exert control.

Effective interventions depend on identifying the function of the behavior. Some problems need clearer procedures; others require attention to the interaction that keeps producing the same result.

Progress Is Often Practical

Parents sometimes begin counseling hoping the other person will change substantially. That may happen in some areas, while many enduring differences remain.

A former spouse may continue to be inflexible. A parent who dislikes texting may remain terse. The two households may maintain different rules. Neither parent may revise their account of why the marriage ended.

Improvement can still be substantial. Parents can become more selective about which disagreements require engagement, shorten their messages, handle schedule changes without reopening historical arguments, keep children out of adult communication, establish predictable reimbursement procedures, and allow new partners to participate in family life without repeatedly turning their presence into a dispute.

Co-parenting counseling is concerned with the family these parents still have to manage after separation. Progress becomes visible when the unresolved parts of the former relationship exert less influence over schedules, decisions, money, communication, and the children who continue moving between the two homes.

References

van Dijk, R., van der Valk, I. E., Deković, M., & Branje, S. (2020). A meta-analysis on interparental conflict, parenting, and child adjustment in divorced families: Examining mediation using meta-analytic structural equation models. Clinical Psychology Review, 79, 101861. Corrigendum published 2021 in Clinical Psychology Review, 88, 102060.

Lamela, D., Figueiredo, B., Bastos, A., & Feinberg, M. (2016). Typologies of post-divorce coparenting and parental well-being, parenting quality and children’s psychological adjustment. Child Psychiatry & Human Development, 47, 716–728.

Regina Abayev, JD, LMFT provides court-ordered co-parenting counseling for separated and divorced parents in Hermosa Beach, the South Bay, and greater Los Angeles. Learn more about Court-Ordered Co-Parenting Counseling.

Previous
Previous

When Desire Changes in a Long-Term Relationship: Part 1

Next
Next

Why Humans Cry