The Myth of the "Affair-Proof" Relationship

Search for ways to “affair-proof” a marriage and you will find plenty of advice about prioritizing the relationship, having more sex, scheduling date nights, maintaining boundaries with other people, and paying attention when you begin to feel disconnected. Most of this is sensible advice, although none of it can provide what the phrase affair-proof implies: a way to ensure that betrayal will never happen.

Two people can build a close marriage, talk openly about sex and dissatisfaction, protect time together, and take their commitment seriously, and one of them can still have an affair. Each person remains capable of making choices that the other cannot control.

What couples can do is understand more about the circumstances in which each of them may be vulnerable to crossing a boundary they believe they would never cross.

Beyond “I Would Never Do That”

Most people enter committed relationships intending to be faithful, so asking an engaged couple whether they plan to have an affair does not tell me very much. In premarital counseling, I am more interested in what each person thinks could compromise their judgment or integrity in the relationship.

The answers can be uncomfortable. Someone may rely heavily on attention from other people when they feel unsuccessful or unappreciated, while another person knows that alcohol changes their judgment. Conflict at home may make the attention of someone who feels easier to talk to especially appealing. Sexual dissatisfaction, loneliness, resentment, professional success, travel, insecurity, or a difficult period in the marriage can also change the way a person responds to attention or opportunity.

These circumstances do not cause affairs or excuse them, and people encounter them every day without violating their commitments. They are still useful to think about because knowing where you are vulnerable makes it easier to recognize a situation before you have explained away a series of decisions that would once have concerned you.

I am less reassured by I would never do that than by someone who has thought seriously about the question. Confidence in your character is valuable, but character does not require pretending that you are immune to validation, attraction, resentment, loneliness, poor judgment, or self-deception.

Privacy, Secrecy, and the Decisions in Between

People in long-term relationships are entitled to privacy. They do not need to disclose every thought, fantasy, attraction, or conversation to their partner.

Secrecy becomes more important when you begin withholding information because you know disclosure would change your partner's understanding of what is happening.

You stop mentioning how often you communicate with a colleague, delete a message because you do not want your partner to see it, or begin discussing your marriage with someone whose attention has become increasingly important to you. Perhaps you continue to believe that nothing inappropriate has happened, while also taking steps to make sure your partner cannot see enough to form their own opinion.

Shirley Glass wrote about this process using the concept of “walls and windows,” describing the gradual movement of intimacy and information outside the primary relationship while secrecy increases within it. I find the concept useful because many affairs develop through a series of decisions that can be individually minimized long before the people involved are willing to describe the relationship as an affair.

The relevant question may therefore come earlier: What am I doing now that I would be uncomfortable doing if my partner were sitting next to me?

The Conversations People Avoid

Some subjects are difficult to raise in a marriage because there may be consequences once they are spoken aloud. Telling your partner that you are unhappy with your sex life, attracted to someone else, resentful, lonely, bored, worried about your drinking, or uncertain about some aspect of the relationship can change the conversation at home in ways you cannot entirely predict.

That uncertainty gives people plenty of reasons to remain quiet.

Silence, however, can allow a private version of the relationship to develop alongside the shared one. Resentment becomes something you think about rather than discuss. Loneliness becomes familiar. Sexual dissatisfaction continues while both people avoid the conversation. Attraction to another person becomes easier to justify because it seems to exist separately from whatever is happening at home.

Couples do not need to report every passing attraction to each other, and disclosure is not an insurance policy against infidelity. There is still a difference between having a private thought and beginning to organize part of your life around keeping information from your partner.

The Relationship Before the Affair

After an affair, couples often want to understand what was happening in the relationship beforehand. There may have been years of distance, very little sex, unresolved resentment, loneliness, conflict, or avoidance, and understanding that history can become an important part of couples therapy.

It is also important to keep responsibility clear. Problems in a marriage can belong to both people, while the decision to have an affair belongs to the person who made it.

Keeping those issues separate allows a couple to examine the relationship without using its problems to explain away the betrayal. The partner who had the affair may need to understand how they gave themselves permission to cross boundaries, what they concealed, what they told themselves while doing so, and what made continued secrecy possible. The couple may also need to examine the relationship they had before the affair and decide what needs to change if they remain together.

Those conversations eventually intersect, but they do different work.

Talking About Fidelity Before There Is a Crisis

Couples often spend surprisingly little time defining fidelity. They may have clear agreements about sex and much less clarity about emotional intimacy with someone else, communication with former partners, private messaging, pornography, flirtation, financial secrecy, or friendships with people to whom there is an attraction.

It is worth discussing these questions before one person is defending conduct the other already experiences as a betrayal.

It is also worth knowing what each of you is likely to have difficulty admitting. What kinds of attention are especially compelling to you? What happens to your judgment when you are angry with your partner, lonely, drinking, traveling, feeling unsuccessful, or receiving attention you have been missing? At what point would you expect your partner to tell you that a friendship or attraction had begun to change?

There is no way to eliminate risk from a long-term relationship, and trying to do so through surveillance creates problems of its own. What couples can do is become less dependent on the assumption that fidelity will take care of itself and more willing to talk specifically about what they are asking each other to protect.

Regina Abayev, JD, LMFT works with couples dealing with infidelity, betrayal, intimacy concerns, and relationship crises in Hermosa Beach and throughout the South Bay, including Manhattan Beach, Redondo Beach, and Palos Verdes. Online couples therapy is available throughout California. Learn more about infidelity and betrayal therapy, couples therapy, couples intensives, or request a consultation.

Previous
Previous

More Than Just Closeness: Defining True Intimacy in a Disconnected World

Next
Next

A Guide to Different Types of Couples Therapy: Approaches, Strengths, and Limitations